How we calculate
Every number on ForeverTavern comes from game data or from a calculation described here. When a value is an estimate, the page shows it as a range or says what it is based on.
Gear ranked by stat weights
Items are ranked per spec with our stat weights: each item is ordered by the sum of each stat multiplied by its weight, compared within the same slot and 10-level bracket. Pages show the resulting order (#1, #2…) and the stats that count, never the underlying number: it is an estimate to compare items within a slot, not a claim that one item is the right choice for everyone.
On gear lists, each slot lists the highest-ranked items whose source we know (drop, quest, recipe, vendor, reputation or PvP) and that is open in WoW Forever. An item is not listed first when its only known source is inside a raid that is in the game client but not open in WoW Forever (Molten Core, Blackwing Lair, Zul'Gurub, Ahn'Qiraj, Naxxramas: Blizzard's raid announcement names only Onyxia's Lair, Barrow Deeps and Hyjal Summit, opening December 9, 2026), inside an announced instance that has not opened yet, or comes only from Classic data. Those items are never hidden: they are named on their own line, "Ranked higher", with the reason. When none of the 10 highest-ranked items qualifies, the slot says so.
The weights are our own. No WoW Forever source publishes stat weights, so they start from values used for Classic, adjusted against WoW Forever class guides and against the talents of the most planned level 60 build, each change noted with its reason. They are set for level 60 and used for every level bracket.
A spec's weights are medium confidence when a level 60 build exists and every talent of that build that converts one stat into another is counted in a weight. They are low confidence otherwise, No spec is high confidence.
Special effects we cannot put a number on are flagged on the item and do not count in the ranking. Who can wear an item follows the class armor and weapon rules; when the game data restricts an item to some classes, that list wins.
The rankings only list weapons that are plausible choices for the spec. For hunters, a melee weapon with caster stats (Intellect, Spirit, mana regeneration, spell power) and no Agility, attack power, armor penetration or weapon skill is left out of the hunter rankings, unless the game reserves it for hunters. It can still be equipped: this is our editorial choice, not a game rule.
Ratings convert to percentages as the game tables of the WoW Forever client say: 14 critical strike rating, 10 hit rating or 12 dodge rating give 1%, the same at every level from 1 to 60.
Stat priority per spec
The main order is the one published by a WoW Forever class guide, shown as the guide lists it, with its name, a link and the date we read it. When an official hotfix changes the spec after the guide's last update, or the guide shows no date, the block says so.
Our own order, ranked by our stat weights per item-budget point, is shown only for level 60 PvE, when the spec's weights are medium confidence and the order agrees with the guide: no stat the guide lists is left out and no two stats are in the opposite order. Otherwise the block says why it is not shown.
Under each stat, the block lists what we can state: the rating conversion from the game tables, the talents of the most planned level 60 build that convert or raise the stat (with their text and the ranks taken), and older vanilla rules, labelled as not confirmed for WoW Forever. When an official hotfix changed a talent and the talent text has not caught up, the hotfix value is shown with a link.
The hit cap is the vanilla rule against raid bosses (9% for special attacks, also given by WoW Forever guides) minus the hit talents of the build, with the calculation shown. No number is given when the build is missing, when a talent's hit bonus is not confirmed for that kind of attack, or for spells, where the vanilla rule (16%) and WoW Forever guides (17%) disagree, unless the spec's guide gives the number. There is no PvP stat priority: no WoW Forever source publishes one.
Talent order per spec
The talent order on a spec page is the one most often planned in the talentsforever calculator, credited and linked next to it. It is a count of plans people made before the game launched, not a guide's advice: leveling orders come from plans made between 18 September and 4 November 2026, counted on 5 November and not recounted since; the level 60 build is the one with the most activity on that site, counted on 4 November 2026.
For each block of ten levels, talentsforever counts how many plans hold exactly the points of the order. We show a leveling order only while at least one plan in five holds those points and no talent left out of the order is taken by more plans than one it contains. That threshold is our own choice, not a statistical test. Past the first block that fails, the order stops; when the first ten levels already fail, no leveling order is shown and the level 60 build is shown alone. We do not show talentsforever's counts or percentages.
The stat priority block cites a talent of that build only when most level 60 plans for the spec take it.
Ranges instead of single numbers
The chance to gain a profession point is 100% while a recipe is orange, then (grey − skill) / (grey − yellow) while it is yellow or green, and 0 once it is grey: 100% at the start of yellow, 50% at the start of green.
Because every craft is a roll, a leveling step shows a range of crafts and materials: the minimum (every craft gives a point), the expected number, and a safe amount to buy, set at the 90th percentile. The range comes from the exact probability distribution and is checked against a 10,000-run simulation.
Profession leveling routes
Routes pick, skill point by skill point, the recipe with the lowest expected cost per point, using the skill-up chances above. Recipes with a cooldown, recipes missing from the current build and Season of Discovery recipes are left out, and by default so are recipes taught by a recipe item.
When a recipe's learning level is unknown (trainer data is not in the game files), the planner assumes it is learned at yellow, so it never suggests a recipe too early. Each step says where to learn its recipe: for a trainer recipe, up to two trainers per faction whose rank covers that learning level (capitals first), among the trainers the leveling routes visit; for a recipe item, the item and how to get it when that is known. Until auction house prices are available, materials sold by vendors use their vendor price, the others an estimate of 4 times their sell price, and a flat 1 gold when neither is known. Costs are therefore estimates.
Leveling planner
For a race and class, the planner chooses level by level the zone that offers the most quest experience you can reach, and explains each choice with its experience and quest count. The published leveling guides are our own summaries of quest hubs, quests to pick up and notable rewards.
Quest levels come first from the quest log as players saw it in WoW Forever, from the open QuestieDB project (shown as "Quest level 15"). Otherwise they come from the leveling guides when a quest appears in one, or are inferred from the experience the quest gives (shown as "Around level 15"). In a cross-check against the guides, 85.6% of levels inferred with zone calibration and 79.2% of levels inferred from experience alone fall within 3 levels of the guide level.
It is a plan by zones, not a step-by-step guide: quest givers, travel time and group quests are not modelled.
Quest chains
A quest is linked to the one before it from signals with a strength each: prerequisites published by the game, in-game quest lines, the order in which players took quests in WoW Forever (open QuestieDB project, only when observed with high confidence across 100 or more characters), consecutive steps in leveling guides, titles in a series, or a description that names the previous quest. Signals are combined and a link is kept from a combined strength of 0.7, and never between opposing factions, different classes or quests that exclude each other.
In a manual check of 23 well-known chains, 20 were right, 2 had a doubtful link and 1 was wrong. Chains are a reading aid, not an official quest line.
Profession pairs by spec
Profession pairs for a spec are ranked from signals read in the game data: crafted items among the spec's first picks by stat weights (bind on pickup counts fully, bind on equip half), consumable recipes useful to its role, engineering gadgets and explosives, and how many recipes use the gathered materials. Each signal is compared across professions, then weighted by goal (leveling, PvE, PvP or gold).
There are no auction house prices, so the gold goal only measures material demand. It is a ranking by our signals, not a verdict on what everyone should pick.
Consumables by spec
On profession pages, elixirs, flasks, food and enchants are matched to specs from the numbers in their effect text as the game publishes it ("Increases Agility by 25", "spell damage by up to 35", "gain 20 Strength", "Regenerate 12 mana per 5 sec"). Nothing is deduced from an item's name, and a sentence with a condition (a zone, a creature type, a camp effect) or a drawback is left out.
Only effects that last at least 10 minutes, or are permanent like enchants, are counted: a 30-second potion is not a buff you keep. Each stat is multiplied by the spec's gear weights (critical strike chance is converted with 14 rating per 1%) and the three highest totals are shown; specs with the same three are grouped. It is a ranking by stat weights, not a claim that one consumable is the right choice for everyone.
Potions and bandages that only restore health or mana have no stat to weigh: they are listed separately, health for every class and mana for the classes that use it.
Racial traits by spec
Each racial trait with a number is listed with whether it applies to the spec role (for example, haste applies to every role). It is an analysis, not a ranking of races.
Addon status and popularity
An addon is marked as working on Forever when a source shows a Forever file: the author's release declares the Forever client, or its files target the Forever interface. Without such data, the status comes from a dated, sourced check listed on the addon page.
The popularity ranking uses only the signals we are allowed to use: GitHub release downloads and GitHub stars from the author's repository. Each addon gets a percentile per signal and the score is their average. An addon without any signal is not ranked and shows no number. Most players install through the CurseForge app, so these counts are a relative signal, never a number of players.
We never host or redistribute addon files: every addon links to its author's page.
Search
Search matches names without accents, tolerates small typos and recognises a few questions: a spec build, where to find an item, a weapon skill for a class, the quests of a zone and a profession skill level.
Where an item comes from
The "Where to find" section of an item lists what is known about how to get it: the PvP rank or reputation it requires and the vendors that sell it, read from the WoW Forever game client; creatures and objects that players saw it drop in WoW Forever, from the open QuestieDB project; quests, recipes and the routes of the leveling guides.
Vendors that players saw selling an item in WoW Forever, with the price they were shown, and the trainers they saw teaching a recipe, with the skill it requires, come from the EG Link data of Efficient Games. Such a vendor line is marked "Seen in WoW Forever"; a list of trainers or vendors is what players have seen, not every one in the game. A price that depends on your reputation says so ("Cheaper at Honored").
For classic items that WoW Forever did not change, drops and vendors also come from the open pfQuest database of the original game (vanilla 1.12). Such a line is kept only when the item has the same id and name and no stat change in Forever, when the creature or vendor exists in WoW Forever data under the same id and name, and when its zone still exists. Forever may still have moved some loot: these lines can be incomplete or outdated for raids and dungeons Forever reworked. Recipes, patterns, plans and other items you do not equip get such a line only when no WoW Forever source is known for them. Every one of these lines, drop or vendor, is marked "Classic, not confirmed for WoW Forever".
Drop chances are never shown or used. An item dropped by many creatures shows "Many creatures" with their level range. An item with no known source, often one new to WoW Forever, shows "Source not known yet".
Buff and nerf labels on hotfixes
The hotfix pages quote Blizzard's official notes as they are. The Buff, Nerf, Mixed and Fix labels next to them are our reading of those notes, made by fixed written rules, not by a person reviewing each change and not by Blizzard.
Buff and Nerf only apply to the power of a player character: a class, spec, pet, talent or spell, an item you equip, a racial trait or a PvP effect. A change is labelled only when its wording leaves no doubt: damage, healing, health, armor, attack or spell power, range or a proc chance that goes up is a buff; a cooldown, a mana, rage or energy cost or a cast time that goes up is a nerf, and the reverse. Reversed wordings have their own rules: "no longer requires" or "can now be cast" is a buff, "can no longer be cast" or "no longer grants" is a nerf. When one note both raises and lowers something, it is labelled Mixed.
Fix means Blizzard describes the change as a bug correction ("Fixed", "now correctly", "than intended"). We do not say whether a fix makes you stronger or weaker.
Changes to enemies, dungeons, quests, the world, professions and prices are never labelled Buff or Nerf. Durations, radiuses, weapon speed, prices and requirements stay unlabelled too, because their effect depends on the case.
Changed means we did not label it, not that it has no effect. When in doubt, we leave a change as Changed: a wrong label would be worse than none.
Which pages we publish
Test and placeholder items are never published. Item lists need at least 8 items and profession categories at least 5 recipes. Aggregated news pages are not indexed, because the titles belong to their authors.
Sources and attributions
Data: Battle.net API. Game data comes from the Battle.net API (Blizzard Entertainment). Skill thresholds and the comparison with Classic come from the game client tables, read through wago.tools.
Leveling guides are our own summaries of quest hubs, quests to pick up and notable rewards, following an established leveling route. Positions on the map are approximate.
Map art: World of Warcraft® © Blizzard Entertainment. News items show a title, a short excerpt and a link to the original article. Streams come from Twitch and videos from YouTube, always linking to the channel.
ForeverTavern is an unofficial fan site, not affiliated with Blizzard Entertainment, with no ads and no account.
Vendors, trainers, NPC roles and positions seen by players: Data from Efficient Games (https://efficient.games), licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), from the EG Link output data set (https://github.com/JIVESCORP/eg-link-output-wowf). ForeverTavern selected, filtered and merged this data across game builds; Efficient Games does not endorse ForeverTavern, and the data is provided as-is, without warranties.